1. Chetri & Thapa [2024] FedCFamC2F 1611
The financial agreement was set aside on the basis that the wife had not received the independent legal advice required under s 90G(1)(b). The solicitor claimed to have advised the wife during a consultation lasting approximately 30–40 minutes but was unable to recall the particulars of the advice provided.
The Court found the solicitor's evidence vague, inconsistent and contradictory. The solicitor had failed to adequately advise the wife regarding her entitlements under the Family Law Act 1975 and the advantages and disadvantages of entering into the agreement.
The Court declined to exercise its discretion under s 90G(1A) to preserve the agreement.
2. Kaimal & Kaimal [2020] FamCA 971
The parties entered into a s 90C financial agreement in July 2018. The wife subsequently challenged the agreement on the basis that she had not received the requisite independent legal advice.
The Court found that the wife had not received the advice required under s 90G(1)(b). The agreement also contained substantive drafting deficiencies, resulting in contractual uncertainty.
The Court declared that the agreement was not binding. The case is particularly relevant to the requirement for solicitors to identify a client's existing rights under the Act before advising how those rights would be affected by the agreement.
3. Daily & Daily [2023] FedCFamC1F 222
The financial agreement was set aside under s 90K(1)(b) on the grounds of contractual uncertainty. The agreement had undergone several revisions and included handwritten amendments made by the husband's solicitor.
The Court found that material provisions were incapable of reasonable interpretation and that severing the defective provisions would deprive the agreement of its substantive purpose.
Significantly, the husband also pursued a professional negligence claim against his former solicitors. The Court found that the negligence claim was established, with the quantum of damages to be determined subsequently.
4. Sullivan & Sullivan [2011] FamCA 752
The wife signed a s 90B financial agreement two days before the wedding, whereas the husband signed the agreement three days after the wedding.
The husband's solicitor failed to adequately advise him that the agreement, if executed after marriage, could not operate as a s 90B agreement or, in its existing form, as a s 90C agreement. The wife was also not provided with a fully executed copy within a reasonable time.
Justice Young found that the agreement was unenforceable, incapable of rectification and not binding pursuant to s 90G.
5. Omar & Bilel [2011] FMCAfam 1430
The parties entered into a s 90C financial agreement. The wife could not speak English and had difficulty understanding written Arabic. The agreement was prepared entirely in English.
Although the wife's solicitor spoke Arabic, the wife had difficulty understanding him due to differences in dialect. The solicitor referred the wife to an interpreter but did not accompany her or supervise the explanation of the agreement.
The Court found that the requisite independent legal advice had not been provided. The solicitor could not delegate responsibility for providing legal advice to an interpreter. The agreement was set aside.

